• Investment Insights
  • Client Newsletters & Events
  • Message Board

Today’s Market Specials: Quality and Value

By: Stephen Duench, Vice-President and Portfolio Manager, AGF Investments Inc

One of the many tenets of quantitative equity analysis is the idea that factors perform differently in relation to each other depending on the stages of a market cycle. Value, high-beta, high-leverage and small-capitalization, for instance, are widely expected to outperform during cyclical upturns, while quality, growth and momentum are the anticipated laggards. But most “quants” also understand this isn’t as simple as it sounds. Yes, these tendencies have played out time and again through history, but rarely does short-term factor performance repeat itself in the exact same way or with the exact same timing.

Take the current environment, for instance. Equity markets have continued to soar since the start of 2021, namely on the promise of an economic rebound from the pandemic-induced recession that occurred last year. And yet, while high-beta, high-leverage and small cap have led the charge higher just as expected, one factor that has been uncharacteristically absent from this leader’s pack is value.

S&P 500 Factor Returns (year-to-date through February 28, 2021)

S&P 500 Factor Returns (year-to-date through February 28, 2021) Chart

Source: AGFiQ with data from FactSet as of February 28, 2021.


In fact, despite clear signs that a new cycle has begun, several metrics synonymous with value, including trailing and forward price/earnings multiples, are associated with some of the weakest returns over the past year, and that trend has only accelerated through January and February, according to our research. Price-to-book, moreover, represents the one – if not only – value ratio that has even remotely held its own from an overall factor perspective over this stretch. And even then, it may be just the exception that proves value’s recent struggles.

S&P 500 Value Factor Performance: Price-to-Book Vs. Other Metrics

S&P 500 Value Factor Performance: Price-to-Book Vs. Other Metrics Chart

Source: AGFiQ with data from FactSet as of February 28, 2021.


Clearly then, value’s recent run represents one of the biggest anomalies in equity markets right now, but it’s also not the only factor being taken to extremes these days. Our research shows that quality, a perennial underperformer during early stages of a new cycle, has not lagged this much in several years relative to other factors. In particular, companies with strong return on equity and high margins relative to their own sectors are faring worse now than they did immediately following the Global Financial Crisis and in the early aftermath of the Tech Wreck in the early 2000s. And because the magnitude of the underperformance has been so steadfast this time around, quality’s prior cycle gains have all but been erased.

In other words, while value has fallen short of expectations by not outperforming at the start of this new cycle, quality is overshooting the mark by underperforming more than expected. But what’s more important to note, perhaps, is that when these two anomalies are taken together, a third anomaly emerges that may have even greater significance to investors. More specifically, our analysis shows the overlap in rolling correlations of price-to-earnings multiples in relation to various quality factors is now near decade-highs, meaning quality and value have rarely been this inexpensive at the same time.

S&P 500 Rolling Correlations Between Value and Quality

S&P 500 Rolling Correlations Between Value and Quality Chart

Source: AGFiQ with data from FactSet as of February 28, 2021.


So, what does all of this mean to investors? At least in the short term, both value and quality could continue down the extreme paths they have recently travelled and put further strain on portfolios that are not properly diversified or that are tilted too heavily towards these factors over others. However, sooner or later, there is every reason to believe that the performance of both these factors will revert to their historical means and make up for lost ground. As such, the potential opportunity of recognizing these factor anomalies may already be at hand. Indeed, there may be no better time to start adding value and quality to a portfolio than now.


Stephen Duench is Vice President and Portfolio Manager, AGF Investments Inc. He is a regular contributor to the Insights and a member of the Highstreet Pooled Funds Investment Team.


The views expressed in this article are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily represent the opinions of Highstreet, AGF Investments Inc, or any of its affiliated companies, products or investment strategies.

The commentaries contained herein are provided as a general source of information based on information available as of March 12, 2021 and should not be considered as investment advice or an offer or solicitations to buy and/or sell securities. Every effort has been made to ensure accuracy in these commentaries at the time of publication, however, accuracy cannot be guaranteed. Investors are expected to obtain professional investment advice.

AGF Investments is a group of wholly owned subsidiaries of AGF Management Limited, a Canadian reporting issuer. The subsidiaries included in AGF Investments are AGF Investments Inc. (AGFI), AGF Investments America Inc. (AGFA), AGF Investments LLC (AGFUS) and AGF International Advisors Company Limited (AGFIA). AGFA and AGFUS are registered advisors in the U.S. AGFI is a registered as a portfolio manager across Canadian securities commissions. AGFIA is regulated by the Central Bank of Ireland and registered with the Australian Securities & Investments Commission. The subsidiaries that form AGF Investments manage a variety of mandates comprised of equity, fixed income and balanced assets.

AGFiQ is a collaboration of investment professionals from AGF Investments Inc. (AGFI), and AGF Investments LLC (AGFUS), a U.S. affiliated registered adviser. This collaboration makes up the quantitative investment team.

Effective January 1, 2020, all members of the Highstreet Pooled Funds Investment Team are employees and registrants of AGF Investments Inc., Highstreet’s parent company. The Highstreet Pooled Funds are investment vehicles offered exclusively to clients of Highstreet Asset Management Inc.

Additional Insights:

Why Rising Bond Yields Aren’t Always Bad for Stocks by David Stonehouse

Three Options for De-clawing a Bond Bear by David Stonehouse

Combine Factors the Right Way by Mark Stacey


Capitol Insights banner

Message from Michael Hodgson

Michael Hodgson Managing Director, Private Client
Michael Hodgson
Managing Director, Private Client

When I last wrote to you during the first few days of 2021, despite the continuation of a “wall of worry” in the markets, I mentioned the beginnings of a general feeling of optimism as vaccines were beginning to be distributed. Unfortunately, the pandemic has taken another run at us with the third wave – people getting ill, hospitals filling up, failing businesses and lockdowns being implemented. Other than the U.S. and UK who have managed to get significant proportions of their populations vaccinated, most of the world is behind the curve in terms of vaccinations, which of course has a knockdown effect on the ability to get global economies growing again.

Read More


Private Client Newsletters

Current Issue

March 31, 2021

Previous Issues

December 31, 2020

September 30, 2020

June 30, 2020


Highstreet 10th Annual Investment Conference (Replay)

In light of what has been a challenging year on many fronts – from a global pandemic to global market volatility – Mark Stacey, Stephen Duench and Greg Valliere provided insights on how the team has navigated 2020, the impact of the U.S. electoral results, and their view going forward.

Watch Replay

Updated Offering Memorandum and Statement of Policies

Updated copies of the Highstreet Pooled Funds Offering Memorandum (July 2020) and Statement of Policies (December 2020) is available directly via the client portal. Alternatively please contact your relationship manager to receive a copy.

Registered Plans

Group Retirement Savings Plan Declaration of Trust

Retirement Income Fund Locked-In Addendum

Retirement Income Fund Declaration of Trust

Retirement Savings Plan Declaration of Trust

Retirement Savings Plan LIRA/LRSP Addendum

Tax Free Savings Account Declaration of Trust